October 2009 :: Jacksonville Criminal Defense Attorney Blog

Written By: Lenorae C. Atter
Family Law Attorney, Wood, Atter & Wolf, P.A.

Bob_Self1%282%29.jpg
In February Haleigh Cummings disappeared. A short time later, the last person to see her, Misty Croslin Cummings married Haleigh's father, Ronald Cummings, which caused people to speculate whether the marriage was due to the Husband-Wife Privilege in Florida, which allows for couples to claim conversations as confidential in Florida.
However, the problem with such speculation in this case is that Haleigh is the child of Ronald, and the Privilege only extends to matters not involving a child of one of the spouses. Since Haleigh is the Child of Ronald, regardless of marriage/divorce, Ronald nor Misty could claim the privilege.
The fact they are divorcing would not be the determining factor in claim of the privilege because public policy mandates that spouses should be able to talk openly and honestly during the marriage without worry for whether the marriage will last forever. That's a good thing, since divorce, especially in Jacksonville, Florida, is still on the rise.

Posted by Keith L. Maynard and Michael A. Atter | Permalink | Email This Post

Posted In: Criminal Law

Written By: Lenorae C. Atter
Family Law Attorney, Wood, Atter & Wolf, P.A.

art.haleigh.cummings.fdle.jpg
In Putnam County, Florida Haleigh Cummings went to bed on February 10, 2009 and has not been seen since. The last person to see Haleigh is Misty Croslin Cummings, who was babysitting the night of the disappearance and soon thereafter married Haleigh's father. Now, the couple is divorcing and blaming the stress of Haleigh's disappearance as the reason. However, most people remain skeptical at this idea.
In Florida, there is a Husband-Wife privilege that gives spouses the ability to claim the privilege in court when their confidential conversations are questioned. This is a privilege because there is a strong public policy that spouses should be able to speak openly and honestly with one another. There was speculation that this privilege led to the marriage of Misty and Ronald Cummings after Haleigh's disappearance. Now that they are divorcing many are wondering if it means Ronald knows more about Misty Cummings's involvement in the disappearance of her stepdaughter. However, the privilege attaches even after the marriage has ended.
More on this issue tomorrow regarding the Husband-Wife privilege in cases involving crimes against children of either spouse.